Does hand position make a difference with how well the naturally gaited horse accepts a snaffle bit contact? Can hand position help or hinder relaxation in the naturally gaited horse? How does hand position impact smooth gaits?
Hand Position & Its Effect on Smooth Gaits
Studying Classical French Dressage has opened my eyes to new concepts in my riding. Not only have these concepts impacted the quality of smooth gaits, but they have also brought joy and harmony to my rides with my naturally gaited horses.
A few years ago, I audited and rode at a few Susan Norman clinics who teaches riding with lightness. She studied under, not one, but two French Classical Dressage Masters: Philippe Karl and the late Jean-Claude Racinet. Susan’s clinics introduced me books and DVDs produced by her protégés. These resources have opened my eyes and awareness to new ways of interacting with my horses that have greatly improved their smooth gaits.
French Classical Dressage Master Philippe Karl’s DVDs Classical vs. Classique and Classical Dressage, volumes 1-4 are excellent resources.
Other favorites are ean Claude Racinet’s book Another Horsemanship and Lisa Maxwell’s DVD Getting Started In Lightness: The French Classical Dressage of Francois Baucher as taught by Jean Claude Racinet presented by one of his students Lisa Maxwell.
While Norman, Karl, and Racinet apply dressage with horses that trot, I have found that the French Classical Dressage principles they teach apply well with the naturally gaited horses as well. What I have learned has produced lightness, balance, mental and physical relaxation, rhythm, engagement, straightness, collection, harmony, and joy. In turn, this humane method has developed full range of motion and quality natural smooth gaits.
The difference hand position makes
Among the differences is hand position. Karl’s teachings opened my eyes to how hand position impacts movement―for the better and the worse. Did you know that where the bit makes contact with the horse’s mouth is the difference between tension or pain and relaxation? Did you know that a tense horse moves differently than a relaxed horse? I didn’t have this awareness until I began to study Karl’s dressage application and begin to understand his philosophy.
For years I had been instructed to maintain a low hand position. Raising my hands to cue my horse was frowned upon. According to Karl, riding with low fixed hands applies tongue pressure. The horse’s response to this pressure is pain or tension and resistance. This leads to avoiding contact by going behind the bit and over flexing; going above the bit and becoming hollow; or getting tense in the jaw leading to a braced back. For the naturally gaited horse, a braced back leads to pacing, step pacing, a hard hollow trot, or stiff movement―certainly not the smooth gaits I am aiming for!
There is a big difference between riding my horse with low fixed hands and riding my horse with higher hands for cueing. A low fixed hand position presses the bit into my horse’s tongue which produces pain, tension and resistance. Cueing with higher hands makes contact with the less sensitive corners of my horse’s lips. Once my horse responds to the cue, I lower my hands to a neutral position with a light following contact. This means I gently follow the natural head and neck motion. If my hands remain in a low fixed position, it accentuates the bracing, pacing and rough gaits.
Watch: Rider Position and Effect on Smooth Gaits
The purpose of nosebands
Another eye-opener for me was the use of nose bands and flash attachments. For years, I showed my horses at dressage competitions. A quiet mouth was prized, so we rode with nose bands and flash attachments to keep the horse’s mouth closed.
Karl rides with a loose nose band or no nose band at all. Why? This permits the horse to freely open its mouth, taste the bit, salivate, and swallow to encourage relaxation. When a horse is ridden in a snug fitting noseband with or without a flash attachment, it can prevent the horse from swallowing. When you see excessive foam dripping from the horse’s mouth, it is likely that the horse isn’t swallowing. A little salivation is good, as long as the horse is able to swallow. When the horse is unable to swallow, this can lead to mental and physical tension which leads to a braced back. For naturally gaited horses, a braced back leads to pacing, step pacing, a hard hollow trot, or stiff movement―definitely not the smooth gaits I seek.
While educating the horse to the rider’s hands, the rider will have higher hands in training until the horse finds its balanced. Once the horse finds balance, the rider’s hands can be lowered to a neutral position.
A bit maker’s perspective
I recently watched a YouTube video: Dale Myler Bitting Series: #1 Understanding Bit Resistance (below) that reinforces Karl’s belief about tongue pressure. Mylar believes that riding the horse with tongue pressure cuts off the horse’s ability to salivate and swallow which distresses the horse. When the bit presses into the tongue by low fixed hands, the tongue begins to affect the horse’s ability to breathe. Adding to this, tension in the jaw encourages the horse to travel on the forehand and shortens the horse’s depth of stride.
Now, I certainly don’t want these qualities for my naturally gaited horses. Do you?
Thinking this through, as I ride my naturally gaited Tennessee walking horses and fox trotting mare, I apply a higher hand position for cueing, then a light neutral position that gently follow the natural head and neck motion. This helps keep my gaited horses relaxed in the jaw, accepting the snaffle bit contact, and has improved our smooth gaits.
I hope this is helpful. Let me know your thoughts by sending a message.
The Lesson I didn’t Expect was the Lesson I needed Most
How many of you have trailered in for a lesson or clinic with expectations, only to be caught by surprise? What was your reaction? I’ll tell you about mine…
Ecole de Légèreté (School of Lightness) is for ALL horses
If you have been following Naturally Gaited the last few years, you know how much I respect the teachings of Classical French Dressage Master Philippe Karl and his training philosophy and methodology called the Ecole de Légèreté (School of Lightness).
In the last few years, Ecole de Légèreté clinics have come to the United States to host teacher certification training. This is a long process and for the dedicated few, they become certified Ecole de Légèreté instructors. I am thrilled that the United States is hosting more and more Ecole de Légèreté teacher certification clinics and even more excited that the United States has teachers in training with a handful of certified Ecole de Légèreté instructors.
What I love so much about Ecole de Légèreté, is that it is training “for” the horse. It meets the horse’s needs, not by the demands of the rider. It isn’t a “make” the horse do, it is an “ask” the horse to do philosophy that builds partnership, harmony, and trust between horse and rider. Ecole de Légèreté teaches the rider a balanced riding position and effective use and timing of rein, leg, seat and weight aids to bring the horse into balance, relaxation, rhythm, connection, engagement, straightness and collection over time.
Best of all, Philippe Karl believes that if the training is good, it will work with all horses, not just the talented ones. This includes the upper level movements such as piaffe, passage, and Spanish walk.
And if Ecole de Légèreté benefits all horses, I will add, including naturally gaited horses.
In 2016, while on vacation in Seattle, WA, I learned of Nichole Walters, an Ecole de Légèreté instructor in training. I took a few lessons on her school horse while I was in Seattle, and she got me started on my path.
I spent the first two lessons just working in hand—not exactly what I had in mind.
Was I disappointed? If I am honest, yes. However, these lessons were foundational and exactly what I needed to learn BEFORE I applied these concepts in the saddle, such as following the horse’s head and neck with a light, equal connection to the horse’s mouth. Learning these in-hand exercises made it so much easier for both me and the horse when I began riding.
Ecole de Légèreté is coming to the Midwest
Since 2016, I have been applying what Nichole taught me with her school horses at home with my naturally gaited horses. I have longed to audit and/or ride at an Ecole de Légèreté clinic, but they have been so far away until now.
Ecole de Légèreté is coming to Schmitt Training Center in Somerset, Wisconsin October 2019 and taught by Master Ecole de Légèreté clinician Bertrand Ravoux. He is one of only six Master clinicians in the world (which includes Philippe Karl). What a treat to witness this training in person! Auditing space is limited, so I mailed my check in right away. Nothing will keep me from witnessing Ecole de Légèreté first hand!
The lessons I didn’t expect
Excited to know of like-minded instructors near me, I trailered both of my naturally gaited horses to Schmitt Training Center to take some lessons with owners Rick and Carrie Schmitt. Before I had arrived, I gave Rick and Kari background on my naturally gaited horses: where we are in our dressage training, what we have been working on, and some of our challenges.
I came to my lessons equipped for Ecole de Légèreté and to work on lateral exercises with my naturally gaited foxtrotting horse Lady and maybe dabble with some counted walk and piaffe with my naturally gaited Tennessee walking horse Makana.
I never rode either horse. Instead we worked in hand!
Was I disappointed? If I am honest, yes, I was a little bit disappointed. With over 30 years studying dressage, I thought we would have had some saddle time. Sigh.
Come on Jennifer, dust off your pride and put on your big girl pants! Just how much do you think you can cover in a 45-minute lesson!
I realized that if I had held on to a disappointed attitude, I would have missed the miracles I had just experienced. And miracles they were!
These lessons weren’t the lessons I had expected, but they were the lessons we needed most.
Meeting the horse where the horse is at
In each 45-minute lesson, Rick, a natural horsemanship trainer, focused on the challenges I mentioned, so each horse received the training they needed, and I receive the education I needed to help my horses where they’re at right now. Each lesson taught me how to more effectively communicate with each horse and meet their individual needs. This is something that I missed by learning on a school horse in Seattle and reading Philippe Karl’s books and watching his videos.
While I receive excellent information through lessons on a school horse and watching videos and reading books that I can apply with my horses, this information isn’t like the first-hand, one-on-one instruction I get in a lesson with my horse. This is a big difference. The former teaches me important concepts. The latter meets me and my horse where we are at.
For me, there is no better way to learn than by taking lessons with my own horse. I LOVE learning. One clinician referred to learning a new approach as adding another tool to your training tool box. In this case, I added two new tools leading to two miracles.
Miracle #1: The secret to establishing contact with a horse that pulls the reins away
My fifteen-year-old naturally gaited foxtrotting horse Lady loves to be ridden on a long floppy rein with no contact, but there is no two-way communication on a long floppy rein. Dressage requires that the horse accepts and follows an even, steady snaffle bit contact and that the rider maintains a steady, light, even connection with the horse through the reins. This also means that the rider remains relaxed in the shoulders, elbows, and hands to FOLLOW the natural head and neck motion of the horse—whether that be following the horse as I direct her to lower her head from a collected walk position to a free walk position or following the natural head and neck motion of the walk, flat walk, running walk, or fox trot.
The challenge I have had with Lady is that each time I take up a light even contact with a snaffle bit, Lady will yank the reins out of my hands after a few strides. This has developed a herky-jerky bit connection: she’s light for a few steps, and then WONK, she grabs the bit and yanks the reins out of my hands. In anticipation of her doing this, I get tense in my shoulders, arms and hands which aggravates the situation. Lady doesn’t trust my hands so she pulls and I don’t trust that she will accept a light stead contact with the bit so she doesn’t.
So why does Lady yank the bit out of my hands? Maybe someone was rough with her mouth in her first seven years before my friend purchased her from the sale barn? Maybe she likes to be on the forehand and is resisting coming into balance? Or maybe I am not following enough with my hands and Lady doesn’t trust my connection?
Lateral exercises can help develop connection and supple the naturally gaited horse.
I have tried lateral exercises which get Lady light until I turn her into a straight line and then she’s back to yanking the bit out of my hands. I have tried lifting my hands higher to connect with the corners of her lips which are less sensitive, and I have vibrated the reins up whenever she leans on them. This helps her get light for a few steps and then WONK. Here we go again.
I have also tried all types of bits from hollow mouth to regular snaffles with one joint and two joints to curbs. Lady can be ridden on a floppy loose rein in a curb, but that’s not dressage. She needs to learn how to accept a light even contact with a snaffle bit. One person encouraged me to ride her in a twisted wire snaffle, but in my opinion, all a harsh bit does is teach the horse bit avoidance rather than bit acceptance.
Teaching Lady a light, even, steady, following contact with the snaffle bit to the ground while working in-hand makes it so much easier when in the saddle.
Rick showed another way—establishing contact while working in hand. He showed me how to maintain a light, even, steady, following contact with both reins AT ALL TIMES—no more herky-jerky, contact-on-contact-off connection with Lady. Teaching me and Lady how to have a light, even, steady, following contact from the ground will make it so much easier from the saddle.
After working Lady in-hand, it made it a lot easier to teach her a light, even, steady, following contact with the snaffle bit while in the saddle.
And Rick is right! The next day, I worked Lady in hand applying everything we learned the day before. Then I got on and we rode with light, even, steady, following contact. She followed the bit in a variety of lengths, and I followed her natural head and neck motion. There was no pulling at a walk. This light, even, steady, following bit connection is essential for a two-way conversation. It is a miracle!
Lady’s foxtrot had moments of light, even, steady, following contact in balance.
Miracle #2: The secret to redirecting an emotional, insecure and reactive mare to relaxation
My fifteen-year-old naturally gaited Tennessee walking horse Makana can be challenging to ride when there are lots of distractions. Whether it is a plastic bag blowing in the wind, birds darting in and out of the bushes, the amplified sound of an announcer, or being in an indoor arena.
Makana is reactive, emotional, spooky and insecure. She needs a trusted leader—only some days, I feel like I’m riding a keg of dynamite. When she is insecure and reactive, shying, spooking, spinning, and bolting, I become insecure and feel like I need to protect myself from falling off. (My grandma body doesn’t bounce like it used to.)
The combination of our insecurity just encourages more insecurity—she doesn’t trust that I will keep her safe and I don’t trust that I will survive the ride without injury!
Our lesson made the perfect environment to address Makana’s anxiousness and reactivity. “You can’t teach a nervous horse to stand still,” Rick said. “Instead you can redirect her observant awareness of her environment by engaging her intelligence and directing her to relaxation.”
Working lateral exercises with the naturally gaited horse in-hand can help calm those that are reactive and environmentally aware.
Rick showed me ways to work with Makana by establishing a light contact with one rein that worked on the outside of her face by the bar of the fulmer snaffle bit. While holding a light touch of the rein and standing in place by her shoulder, I focused my mind on moving her hind foot a step under her body with a simple cluck and as soon as she did, I released her to relaxation.
Engaging the Mind What was fascinating about this approach was that there was no urging her with my body language or using a whip to get her to step under. She was encouraged to figure it out with her mind and her ability to notice small details. Connecting to her with one rein, visualizing in my mind what I wanted her to do, I used a simple cluck to engage her while I stood still. As soon as she did what I visualized, I released her to relaxation so that she knew that’s what I wanted.
After the one hind leg stepping under, we changed the exercise to a front leg crossing over to a release to relaxation. Then both hind leg and fore leg crossing over a step to a release to relaxation, and finally a rein back to a release to relaxation. All of these exercises utilized the same a one rein connection, no prompting on my part to make her do the exercise, other than clucking and visualizing in my mind, and a release to relaxation as soon as Makana did what I thought.
These exercises utilized Makana’s sensitivity, intelligence and gift for noticing minute details. They rewarded her efforts with relaxation, and established two-way communication between us where she realized I can help her relax in reactive environments.
Within a few minutes through these in-hand exercises, I became the trusted leader Makana needs and I have purposed to become.
The instruction I received from Rick was insightful, timely, and meaningful. He ended my lesson with Makana in teaching her to side pass to the mounting block and stand still. He used the same one rein connection, visualizing, and clucking to engage method that he used with the other exercises. In less than three minutes, Makana knew exactly what Rick meant. My jaw dropped watching Makana side pass to the mounting block and stop. I was humbled to realize how intelligent Makana is, and I am encouraged with new tools to communicate with her to help her relax in distracting environments and develop the trusted partnership I’ve always wanted in every circumstance.
Working lateral exercises with the naturally gaited horse in the saddle was easier after the in-hand work.
The next day, Makana worked through the in-hand exercises and within minutes she was relaxed. Plus, mounting was a breeze! When I got in the saddle, I did the exact same exercises with a release to relaxation. She was much calmer and less reactive on the woodsy side of the outdoor arena.
Makana went on to produce a confident naturally gaited flatwalk without spooking.
So what do these two miracles have to do with Ecole de Légèreté training methodologies. As Rick said, “Natural horsemanship is kind of like preschool. It meets the horse where the horse is at.” For Makana, Rick taught me how to meet her need for safety and trust me to direct her there and for Lady, he taught me how to establish a two-way communication through a light, even, steady contact. Now each horse is in a better place to continue our Ecole de Légèreté (in gait).
For more information about auditing the Ecole de Légèreté (School of Lightness) clinic coming to Somerset, WI and taught by Master Ecole de Légèreté Clinician Bertrand Ravoux, visit www.legerete-usa.com.
Gaited dressage doesn’t require trot, riding in an arena, an English saddle, or showing. You might be surprised what else gaited dressage doesn’t require and all the benefits you and your gaited horse can gain.
What is Gaited Dressage?
By Jennifer Klitzke
Gaited dressage doesn’t require trot. It doesn’t mean that you have to wear fancy clothes, buy an English saddle, fit your horse with shoes, and it doesn’t mean that you’re confined to riding in an arena. You might be glad to know gaited dressage doesn’t require that you show!
Best of all, you’ll be glad to know that gaited dressage is not abusive. It never uses harsh bits, heavy shoes, chains, pads, artificial enhancements, or mechanical devices to develop natural smooth gaits. No not ever!
As long as you are riding your smooth gaited horse in a well-fitting and balanced saddle and a comfortable and appropriate snaffle bit, gaited dressage embraces your English or western preference—whether you show or not.
What gaited dressage is
Gaited dressage is a humane way to train the smooth gaited horse and rider. Through ongoing lessons, the rider develops a balanced riding position and effective use and timing of rein, leg, seat and weight aids. These aids lead the horse into relaxation of mind and body, balance, rhythm, forward movement without rushing, connection, symmetry, and collection. This foundation helps the gaited horse develop strength and flexibility, full range of motion, quality smooth gaits, and a partnership of harmony and trust.
Gaited dressage is versatile
Gaited dressage is a consistent communication language between the rider and horse that can be taken wherever you and your horse go and whatever you do in or out of an arena, along the trail, while negotiating sneaky cows in the sorting ring, jumping a course of fences, and more.
You can even show gaited dressage
There are many schooling shows, breed shows and even virtual open shows that offer gaited dressage. Showing gaited dressage is a great way to receive written feedback from a trained dressage professional about your horse’s training as it relates to rhythm, relaxation, connection, engagement, straightness, and collection, as well as feedback about your riding position and use and timing of your rein, leg, seat and rein aids.
Gaited dressage teaches the rider how to train the horse
Gaited dressage educates the rider to educate the horse. The rider lears how to lead the horse into relaxation, balance, rhythm, connection, engagement, straightness, collection, and harmony. Over time, these training elements develop full range of motion and quality smooth gaits.
Six ways dressage teaches a rider how to train their gaited horse
1) Rider position and application of aids. The rider develops a balanced riding position over the horse’s center of gravity. In addition, the rider learns the effective use and timing of hand, leg, seat, and weight aids. These aids lead the horse into relaxation of mind and body, even rhythm and tempo, forward movement without rushing, connection with the horse, symmetry, flexibility and strength, and balance, engagement, and collection.
2) Accept and follow contact. Gaited dressage teaches the rider how to teach the horse how to accept and follow a light snaffle bit contact. It also teaches the rider how to follow the horse’s natural head and neck movement with relaxed shoulders, arms, and hands.
3) Feel awareness involves noticing how the rider’s body, breathing, and thoughts impact the horse. Noticing and releasing tension in the rider’s shoulders, arms, hands, hips, back, and jaw, breathing deep into the belly, following the natural head and neck motion of the horse with the hands and following the belly sway of the horse with relaxed hip joints to encourage relaxation in the horse. Becoming aware of the timing of aids and the feeling of when the horse is in the moment for the cue.
4) Feeling of rightmeans knowing what is feels like when the horse is relaxed in its mind and body; balance on all four legs; moving with steady rhythm and even strides; moving forward without rushing; having symmetry (meaning evenly flexible in both directions); and developing engagement from the hindquarters, abdominal muscles and chest to lower the hindquarters, lift the back and wither head and neck over time.
This also means learning to notice when the horse is on the forehand, tense in the lower jaw, hollow in the back, disengaged with its hind legs, crooked, stiff, and rushing.
When a rider has developed this feel awareness, they can restore the horse to the feeling of right through effective use and timing of leg, seat, weight, and rein aids.
5) Consistency training helps the rider develop a consistent communication language with the horse through the use and timing of leg, rein, seat, and weight aids. This consistent communication leads the gaited horse into more and more moments of relaxation, balance, rhythm, connection, forward movement without rushing, and symmetry. Developing the feeling of right helps you notice when corrections are needed to bring the horse back to the feeling of right. And the proper timing of rewarding the horse early and often.
6) Becoming a trusted leader with the gaited horse through an ongoing, two-way dialogue. It requires the rider to declutter their mind and heart and be present with the horse, listening to and seeking to understand what the horse is saying, and learning to effectively communicate with the horse and lead them into the feeling of right. Then listening to the response of the horse for adjustments as needed.
Gaited dressage is more than a training system
Gaited dressage is an on-going journey of a relationship between the rider and horse over time. This takes time to develop. Yet nothing is more deeply rewarding when the communication, connection, and harmony between a rider and a smooth gaited horse lead to the horse feeling safe enough to accept the rider as a trusted leader.
How gaited dressage benefits the rider
Improves the rider’s balance and effective riding position
Improves the rider’s communication with their smooth gaited horse through the effective use and timing of leg, seat, weight, and rein aids which helps the horse develop greater trust, relaxation and harmony with the rider
Developing the smooth gaits are easier on a rider’s body
Aging dressage riders who have invested years of time and money taking dressage lessons on trotting horses can apply their knowledge and skill with a gaited horse and enjoy a smooth ride that is easier on the body
Gaited dressage can be taken on the trail where the rider can cover a lot of ground quickly and the rider’s body won’t pay for it later!
How gaited dressage benefits the gaited horse
By relaxing the naturally gaited horse’s mind, the horse is more teachable
By relaxing the horse’s jaw and back, pace can be replaced with smoother natural four-beat gait
Gaited dressage can break cross canter, a later canter, and a four-beat canter into a true, three-beat canter
Through the effective use and timing of rein, seat, leg and weight aids the naturally gaited horse can be led into relaxation, balance, rhythm, connection, engagement, straightness, collection, and harmony to improve the horse’s full range of motion and quality of natural gaits on cue
With lateral exercises like the shoulder-in the horse can find balance, activate the abdominal muscles to lift the back, engage the hind and develop a deeper stride beneath the body which will lengthen the stride overall from hind foot to hind foot
By connecting the energy from the horse’s hindquarters through the horse’s body to the bit while riding with a light and even contact on both reins following the head and neck motion, the naturally gaited horse can develop a consistent head nod in the flat walk, running walk, and fox trot
Most of all, smooth gaited horses flourish when ridden using dressage methods that build trust, relaxation, and respect.
May 15, 2019 was a very sad day. Two wonderfully generous people who impacted my life passed away. One a friend. The other a man I never met.
That man is William Villella. Over 17 years ago, he had a vision and built an indoor arena for the community and bring horse people together to enjoy and have fun with their friends. He named it Hi Circle Vee Ranch.
This is how William impacted my life. Yet, he created more than an indoor arena for public riding, William built a community of fun-loving, helpful, and inclusive horse people. I’ve been around many equestrian groups over the years, and I’d have to say that the people I’ve met at Hi Circle Vee have been some of the best.
Hi Circle Vee is where all of my horses were introduced to cows. It is where me and Makana and Lady learned sorting through the many clinics offered. Later we joined sorting leagues where we met so many wonderful people.
And Hi Circle Vee is where Makana and I first rode with Larry Whitesell.
Larry Whitesell explaining the feeling of shoulder-in to me and Makana.
Thank you William for your generosity and thoughtfulness for creating such a warm and inviting place to ride and meet new horse friends. We will miss you! Rest in peace.
Hi Circle Vee will be closing on May 31, 2019 which will bring an end to the community William had built. My heart and prayers go out to his family and friends, and to all of us who will say “goodbye” to William’s legacy.
You must be logged in to post a comment.